Based on the work of the ETUI-REHS Research Group on Transnational Trade Union Rights (co-ordinator, Professor Brian Bercusson), this publication assesses the Opinions of the Advocates General of the Court in Laval and Viking cases and proposes six solutions which may be considered satisfactory from the point of view both of legal doctrine and industrial relations practice.
Chapter headings:

 

  • Collective action is not subject to and falls outside the scope of the Treaty’s economic free movement provisions (the Albany solution);

 

  • Employers may not use economic freedoms in the Treaty against trade unions taking collective action (horizontal direct effect);

 

  • Subsidiarity excludes EC competence to regulate collective action;

 

  • Workers’ right to take collective action balances employers’ economic freedoms;

 

  • Interpreting the Treaty as recognising that collective action is essential to the effective functioning of the internal market;

 

  • Ordre communataire social protects collective action by workers and trade unions.
Buy printed version
€ 15.00
en

Related content

Posting of workers before national courts

Intra-EU employee posting remains a politically and legally contentious matter that continues to feature on the agendas of lawmakers, trade unions and researchers alike. Numerous cases brought before the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU), as well as recent and ongoing revisions of the posting-related EU legal framework, suggest that... Find out more

Caroline de la Porte, Patrick Emmenegger

The Court of Justice of the European Union and fixed-term workers: still fixed, but at least equal

This Working Paper focuses on the impact of the directive on fixed-term work and the EU's Court of Justice (CJEU) case law concerning fixed-term work from 2007 and 2013. By doing so, this working paper develops an analytical framework to analyse the Europeanisation of labour law with an eye on the literature on labour-market dualisation.The... Find out more

Bettina Wagner, Anke Hassel

Labour mobility in the EU: between economic freedom and labour standards

Transfer stimulates dialogue between the European trade union movement and the academic and research community. It contributes research findings on issues of strategic relevance for trade unions, in particular with regard to developments at the European level. Transfer publishes original peer-reviewed research on issues such as new developments in... Find out more

Roland Erne, Andreas Bieler, Darragh Golden, ...

European collective action in times of crisis

Transfer stimulates dialogue between the European trade union movement and the academic and research community. It contributes research findings on issues of strategic relevance for trade unions, in particular with regard to developments at the European level. Transfer publishes original peer-reviewed research on issues such as new developments in... Find out more

Thorsten Schulten, Torsten Müller

Wages and collective bargaining during the European economic crisis

Since 2008, Europe has been affected by the deepest crisis since the 1930s. This has had a farreaching impact on the economic and social situation of millions of European workers. The most obvious impact has been the dramatic increase in mass unemployment. Today, there are more than 26 million unemployed people in the European Union (EU). It has... Find out more

Nicolas Latteur

Collective action to transform work

Working conditions are getting worse and worse. The harm they are doing to employees makes health and safety at work critical. But rather than just tackling the work-related factors of particular diseases, what is needed is to act on the work relations that are behind the decline in working conditions. Taking ownership of knowledge and modes of... Find out more