Unemployment rates in the EU rose after the economic crisis of 2008, passing 10% in 2012, but with big variations between countries. The worst afflicted had been subject to so-called policies of internal devaluation, aimed at curing unemployment by reducing wage costs. This book provides a comparative study of countries that to varying degrees followed that road (Greece, Spain, Portugal, Ireland) set against others that did not (Germany, UK, Poland).

The analysis points to three main conclusions. The first is that unemployment was not caused by excessive wages. There were issues of competitiveness in some countries but they related to the absence of high-quality export sectors. The second is that internal devaluation did reduce balance of payments current account deficits, but overwhelmingly by reducing living standards and hence imports. It did not trigger higher exports, although in several countries they increased for completely different reasons. The third is that internal devaluation has led to more rather than less unemployment and to less rather than more growth. The book points the way to alternative, and more effective, solutions based on improved competitiveness and more employment following spending and investment in infrastructure, education and research, areas that have suffered in the interests of internal devaluation policies.

Buy printed version
€ 20.00

Table of contents

Full text

Martin Myant, Sotiria Theodoropoulou and Agnieszka Piasna: Introduction

Sotiria Theodoropoulou: Chapter 1 - Severe pain, very little gain: internal devaluation and rising unemployment in Greece

Tom A. McDonnell and Rory O’Farrell: Chapter 2 - Fall of the Irish house of cards

António Bob Santos and Sofia Fernandes: Chapter 3 - Internal devaluation and unemployment: the case of Portugal

Jorge Uxó, Eladio Febrero and Fernando Bermejo: Chapter 4 - Crisis, unemployment and internal devaluation in Spain

Steffen Lehndorff: Chapter 5 - Internal devaluation and employment trends in Germany

Steve Coulter: Chapter 6 - The UK labour market and the ‘great recession’

Ma?gorzata Maciejewska, Adam Mrozowicki and Agnieszka Piasna: Chapter 7 - The silent and crawling crisis: international competition, labour market reforms and precarious jobs in Poland

Key messages of this publication

Related content

Maria Jepsen

Changing labour markets and international organisations

Transfer stimulates dialogue between the European trade union movement and the academic and research community. It contributes research findings on issues of strategic relevance for trade unions, in particular with regard to developments at the European level. Transfer publishes original peer-reviewed research on issues such as new developments in... Find out more

Valeria Pulignano

Work in deregulated labour markets: a research agenda for precariousness

This Working Paper tackles two questions: what counts as work within a deregulated labour market; and what are the implications for the study of precariousness? The paper addresses the traditional dichotomy between paid and unpaid work which obscures how unpaid activities often undercut paid employment. In this light, it suggests a new way of... Find out more

Drifting into labour market insecurity? Labour market reforms in Europe after 2010

This working paper examines the impact of fiscal austerity on EU labour market policies. Using a case study approach, it examines: the extent of change in unemployment benefit levels and policies; the effect of this on groups of workers; and whether the logic of activation policies has shifted. Overall, the broad direction of policy has not altered... Find out more

Myths of employment deregulation: how it neither creates jobs nor reduces labour market segmentation

This book looks at the effects of changes in employment regulation on levels and forms of employment in nine EU countries (Spain, Italy, Estonia, Slovakia, Poland, Germany, France, Denmark, and the UK). It demonstrates that reducing employment protection has brought neither labour market nor economic benefits. Moreover, post-crisis changes were... Find out more

Gabriele Piazza, Martin Myant

Italy's labour market reforms of 2012: did they reduce unemployment?

This Working Paper critically analyses Italy’s labour market reforms of 2012 (Fornero Reform). It focuses especially on a measure designed to cut unemployment and labour-market dualism by reducing the protection against dismissal enjoyed by permanent employees.The main argument of this paper is that labour market reforms focused on promoting... Find out more

Laszlo Horwitz, Martin Myant

Spain’s labour market reforms: the road to employment – or to unemployment?

This working paper looks at recent structural reforms of the Spanish labour market and evaluates them against the government’s stated objectives to reduce unemployment.It concludes that the labour market flexibilisation approach has not helped to reduce unemployment, nor has it contributed to the process of reactivating the long-term unemployed or... Find out more